← PKADB

Lost (2004) series

Discussed in 11 episodes · 14 film takes
PKA Score 3.8/10
Woody
4.4/10
8 takes
Taylor
3.6🦉/7
4 takes
Kyle
5.5/10
2 takes
IMDb 8.3 RT 80%
PKA rates this 4.4 lower than critics

Sentiment over time — how their takes changed across episodes

LovedNeutralHatedPKA 307PKA 373PKA 439PKA 505PKA 571PKA 307: -0.80 (2 takes)PKA 329: +0.60 (1 take)PKA 379: +0.17 (1 take)PKA 410: -0.85 (1 take)PKA 438: -0.88 (2 takes)PKA 456: -0.60 (1 take)PKA 526: -0.73 (3 takes)PKA 542: +0.50 (1 take)PKA 571: -0.85 (2 takes)
Each dot is one episode’s average take (bigger = more takes that episode). Toggle a host to isolate their arc. Voice-verified film/show opinions only.

Every time it came up

▶ PKN 410 @ 32:00 — PKN 410
Discussion of Lost's poor ending with unanswered questions
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“Lost is the opposite lost there were so many loose ends so many what about these powers what about these people”
▶ PKN 571 @ 21:49 — PKN 571
Discussion of Lost's ending and how it disappointed viewers; comparison to Game of Thrones and discussion of how the show built up theories but failed to resolve them
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“These comebacks, it was half a dream. But what half? What parts were dreams? It's hard to believe how writing stabs actually work on a level that big.”
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“And it was literally like Game of Thrones before Game of Thrones because that show ended. And immediately the next day, he's like, I don't know if I hate anything as much as Lost.”
▶ PKA 526 @ 2:35 — PKA 526 w Destiny - Panic Attacks, Destiny Loses Twitch Partners
Extended discussion of Lost's mysterious plot threads, Walt's aging, character deaths, and unsatisfying ending
Kyle ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“they were bad writers because like I said before on this show all they had to do when for example Walt aged big time between season two and three or season one and two he he hit puberty”
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“Lost was amazing. It was a cultural phenomenon, phenom, whatever. And everyone was talking about it. It was like Super Bowl commercials. It was people hanging on the edge. It was the water cooler show of its time, Lost w”
Kyle ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“Instead, they just wrote him off the show”
▶ PKN 526 @ 4:43 — PKN 526
Kyle referenced Lost bunker design for a potential FPS Russia video about building a doomsday bunker
Kyle ✓ voice-verified● neutral · passing mention, not scored
“it was gonna be like the one from lost or something”
▶ PKN 456 @ 46:05 — PKN 456
Discussion of mystery series that failed to adequately explain its mysteries and plot threads; compared to From's need for coherent answers
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“i think that one time they completely explain explain the entire lost universe as a figment of hurley's imagination and he was in like a psych ward and then that explanation just kind of drifted away and they didn't go a”
Kyle · unverified▼ negative
“Every episode of Lost was like a trailer for a movie I'd love to see. And then the movie never came out.”
Kyle · unverified▼ negative
“i remember buying into for that polar bear and lost and thinking man someday they going to tell me about that polar bear and I going to be Ah, they never did. And then that smoke monster. And then it was just never the n”
▶ PKA 542 @ 1:33:01 — PKA 542 w Dick Masterson - Taylor's Basement Contractor, Kyle Da
Death pool discussion mentioning Hurley from Lost
Woody ✓ voice-verified▲ positive
“I still want the big fat guy from Lost. He's a ticker. Oh, I love it. I love it. Hurley's a good one.”
▶ PKA 379 @ 1:18:31 — Painkiller Already #379
Taylor's retrospective on the series, praising early seasons but criticizing the ending
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative · passing mention, not scored
“the whole thing existed in the fat guy's head... none of them... you know what it reminded me of”
Woody ✓ voice-verified◆ mixed
“Loved it. I thought that was so amazing... and then when it ended and they didn't tie together any of those loose ends”
▶ PKA 438 @ 30:18 — Painkiller Already #438
Discussion of the show's poorly received ending
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“I thought the Lost ending was so terribly horrific. I'm still a little mad about it. I'm mad at Lost.”
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“so the polar bears that live on the island and the smoke ghost and all these things just happen and there's no explanation. That's what I kind of feel like Game of Thrones is.”
▶ PKA 329 @ 21:40 — Painkiller Already #329
Discussion of Lost as TV show Ahmed learned English from
Taylor · likely▲ positive
“I remember Lost and 24 were big at the time. So those were my favorite. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly. That's really weird, but I really loved that show”
▶ PKA 307 @ 33:25 — Painkiller Already #307
Extended discussion criticizing Lost's ending and how it disappointed fans with unanswered questions
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative · passing mention, not scored
“I don't think that anybody would mind spoiling Lost. What was it about the end of Lost that people hated so much?”
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“every episode – at the end of every episode, they'd show you what's coming next week. And it was like, oh, I can't wait to see that. We're going to get some big answer, and then we don't.”
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“People have heard me talk about Lost forever, but they had like six different explanations and ways that Lost could go. The way they did wrap it up, I don't even get it or something. I don't know. It sucked.”
▶ PKA 464 @ 1:43:13 — PKA 464 Taylor Bible Story, Lebron's Wig, Aggressive Policeman
Compared to Game of Thrones as another show with disappointing ending
Taylor · unverified▼ negative
“like lost every episode of lost made me want to watch the new thread”